Agenda, Volume 16, Number 3, 2009
Next
Agenda, Volume 16, Number 3, 2009
Table of Contents
Editor
Editorial Committee
Forum
Multi-Criteria Analysis: "Good Enough" for Government Work?
Abstract
Introduction
The emergence of cost-benefit analysis
The theory and practice of cost-benefit analysis
Multi-criteria analysis: atheoretical and impractical
Some comparisons: cost-benefit analysis versus multi-criteria analysis
Whose perspective?
Choice of impacts or effects of government policies and actions
Alternative policies
Valuation of effects or merits of proposals
Efficiency versus equity
Why multi-criteria analysis is fundamentally flawed
Analytical rigour
Implications for government
Conclusions
References
In Defence of Cost-Benefit Analysis
CBA
The differences between CBA and MCA
Criticisms of CBA
Non-commensurability
Income distribution
Accuracy
The current state of Australian project evaluation
References
Assessing the Impact of Regulatory Impact Assessments
International experience with RIAs
The unintended consequences of dealing with unintended consequences
‘Sed quis custodiet ipsos custodes?’
‘If people don’t know what you’re doing, then they don’t know what you’re doing wrong’
Regulating regulation’s regulator
References
Advancing Accountability in Government
Switch on the Data: Changes Needed for Access to Public-Sector Information
References
Can Better Political Governance Give Australia an Improved Political Class?
The governance of political parties: the issue
The present framework
Some Proposals for Reform
Analysis
Error and Design: Economics in (and some Economics of) the Australian Competition Tribunal
Abstract
Introduction
Review in action: three Tribunal decisions
Rates of return and investment
Asset valuation
Airport charging
Why do errors occur?
Implications for regulatory design: Rules and standards
Relation to Australian regulatory regimes
Conclusions
References
Argument
The Global Credit Crisis: Why Have Australian Banks Been So Remarkably Resilient?
Abstract
Introduction
Performance of Australian banks during the current crisis
No bailouts of Australian banks
No US and UK-style liquidity emergency
Australian banks have avoided abnormal loan write-downs
Share prices of Australian banks comparatively resilient
Australian banks have not been downgraded
Explaining the contrasting experience
A culture of intermediation, not securitisation
Australian banks are highly capitalised
A diversified and stable funding base
Healthy profitability
Sound corporate governance
Effective financial system regulation
Separation of commercial banking from social assistance measures
Conclusions
References
Fiddling With the Digital TV Tuner: Recent Adjustments to a Poor Policy
Abstract
Introduction
Digital television policy
Adjusting the original plan
How many homes have digital TV?
Prospects for a 2013 switchover
Are recent policy changes sufficient?
Conclusion
References